Have you ever heard of planting by the signs?
The right time to plant is the subject of a great deal of folk tradition. In preindustrial times, Lawrence County farmers and gardeners relied on received wisdom from their elders to know when to plant and when to reap–and many local folks still swear by these methods.
Some old-time gardeners do not plant warm-weather crops until after Mother’s Day, a tradition which probably doesn’t go back much further than 1908, when the first Mother’s Day was celebrated in the United States.
One popular old aphorism is that most seeds should be planted either by or on Good Friday. On April 10, 1880, Lawrenceburg court official W.T. Nixon noted in his journal: “During the night the wind shifted around and got in the S.W. but not until after frost had formed…the peach crop cut down to one half, some damage done to grape vines…I see my corn is coming up which was planted on good Friday.” In 1880, Good Friday was on March 26.
Nixon did a great deal of work planting the week of Good Friday, recording that he “spent almost the entire evening in garden” on March 25, “having planted Carrots, Okra, corn, and running beans together (Mexican corn – a new kind of sweet corn) then a bed of E. Val. beans.” However, due to a series of hard freezes over the ensuing weeks, he also wrote that he had to replant several of his vegetables.
What Nixon recorded about replanting many of his veggies is the great drawback of planting on Good Friday. The holiday could occur as early as March 20 or as late as April 23, a range of dates that can contain a wild variety of climatological conditions in our zone.
Some traditionalists consult the Farmer’s Almanac to know when to plant. The Almanac’s formula for determining when to plant is a combination of last-frost dates for a particular area combined with a much older tradition of planting by the phases of the moon.
The Almanac’s lunar tradition of planting is very old, and adheres to a formula which says that above-ground crops such as corn and beans should be planted during the waxing moon–when adherents believe the moon’s gravity is drawing moisture out of the earth–and below-ground crops such as carrots and potatoes should be planted during the waning moon, when the moon’s dissipating gravity allows moisture to return deep into the soil.
Similar to planting by phases of the moon, many old-timers and old souls believe in consulting the signs of the Zodiac, sometimes combined with phases of the moon, to know when to plant particular things. This is known as planting “by the signs.” When the sun is “in” a particular constellation, or sign, it is considered to be that sign’s time.
A detailed explanation of this is found in Foxfire 4, a collection of mountain lore edited and published by Eliot Wiggington and his students. Pauline Henson told the Foxfire editors “if you want a lot of cucumbers, plant [the seeds] when the signs are in the twins.” This indicates that, according to Ms. Henson’s estimation, cucumbers should be planted between May 21 and June 20, during the time when the sun is in Gemini.
Lizzie Lovin told Foxfire that “Mamma planted beans when the signs was in the arms. They’d never plant corn when the signs was on the new of the moon; it would grow so high you couldn’t reach the ears. They planted corn on the full moon, and it’d grow short and the ears would be full.”
Planting by body parts adds another wrinkle to the equation. According to the Farmer’s Almanac website, “ancient astrologers believed that each astrological sign of the zodiac influenced a specific part of the body.” The Almanac illustrates this belief with “The Man of the Signs” a diagram which shows which sign of the zodiac is represented by which body part. The arms referenced by Ms. Lovin would indicate that beans should be planted under the sign of Gemini.
Lon Dover told Foxfire “the best time in the world to make Irish potatoes is when the signs are in the feet.” This is under the sign of Pisces, from February 20 to March 20.
What folk wisdom have you heard about planting? Do you follow it?
















